Login Page - Create Account

Support Board


Date/Time: Sun, 22 Nov 2026 13:49:55 +0000



Redesign of Reward Risk Tool Based on TradingView Model [Feature Request]

View Count: 3212

[2026-11-07 18:12:25]
Deenius - Posts: 176
Regarding post #17, this will be out in the next release. For item 3 a basic implementation will be provided.

I upgraded to version 2983 and noticed that some of my suggestions have already been implemented. 👍 Thank you!

I tested the new "Auto Update Entry Target Stop Based On Last Trade Price" setting and have two notes/feature suggestions for improvement:


1. Locking SL & PT at specific price levels while auto-updating the entry

If I enable this new setting, I can now enter positions in live markets using a Market order, with pre-defined stop-loss (SL) and profit-target (PT) levels that I can easily set directly on the chart using the risk/reward (R/R) tool. This eliminates the need to open the Trade Window at all.

I noticed that while adjusting the R/R tool, the automatic updating of the entry price, stop loss, and profit target levels is paused. That is fantastic! It makes setting the SL and PT distances from the entry price extremely precise.

However, this current behavior is only useful when a trader wants to keep the SL and PT at a fixed distance from the entry price—for example, when trading breakouts, where fixed PT and SL distances are frequently used.

A much more common scenario is that a trader already knows in advance where they want to place their SL and PT (for instance, a few ticks above or below the nearest swing high/low) and is simply waiting for the right entry moment. In this case, the SL and PT levels are clearly defined, and the only variable is the entry price. Therefore, we need a solution that allows setting the SL and PT at specific levels while ensuring the R/R tool's entry price continues to auto-update.

I suggest adding a "Disable Auto Update Target Stop After First Update" setting as a companion option to "Auto Update Entry Target Stop Based On Last Trade Price."

Essentially, this setting would do exactly what its name implies. Once the user draws the R/R tool on the chart, the initial entry, stop loss, and target levels are set (just like they work now). However, after that first level update, only the entry price will continue to update. The SL and PT levels will remain right where they were placed.

Naturally, we need to account for situations where, after placing the R/R tool on the chart, the market price reaches the SL or PT level. In such cases, the SL and PT levels must automatically adjust to at least match the entry price to maintain the correct logical positioning of the SL and PT relative to the entry.


2. One-click placement for the R/R tool

When placing the R/R tool on the chart with this setting enabled, it would be much faster if it could be done with a single click. Since we will almost certainly adjust the SL and PT distances from the entry price right after the initial snap to the last price, it is unnecessary to click three times just to place the tool on the chart.

I suggest adding a "Place with One Click" (or "Enable One-Click Placement") setting.

When enabled, the single click would define the entry price level instead of the stop loss, as it currently does. This would make the R/R tool placement workflow identical to standard practices on other platforms that users are already familiar with.

Of course, if the user doesn't define the SL and PT levels at the very beginning of the placement process, the platform needs to generate them automatically. Fortunately, this is quite straightforward by establishing a few simple rules for the SL and PT anchor points:

Vertical distance from the entry:

We can use an ATR indicator (specifically its formula) with a longer period, since the default 14-period is too volatile for this purpose (the value variance is too high). When studying TradingView’s R/R tool, I noticed that the SL and PT distance from the entry typically ranges between 1.5× and 3× ATR(50). So, if Sierra Chart used something like a 2× ATR(50) multiplier, I think it would work really well. Ultimately, this could be a user-configurable setting called something like "Target Stop Distance Multiplier."

Horizontal distance from the entry:

This is also easy to determine. The SL should always be set at the same horizontal position as the Entry Price. The PT should then be shifted a few bars forward (to the right). In TradingView, the R/R tool is always drawn 16 bars/candles away from the entry, which serves as a good guideline for setting the tool's default width.


So those are my notes and improvement ideas. Thank you for considering them and for continuously working on improving this tool. I am genuinely excited about this! It will help a lot of users.
Date Time Of Last Edit: 2026-11-07 20:44:11
[2026-11-07 19:09:22]
Sierra_Chart Engineering - Posts: 25458

8. Easy Movement of the Risk/Reward Tool

If you have watched a few videos of how traders work with the R/R tool, you have surely noticed that they often don't delete it, but simply move it from one place on the chart to another and then just adjust the profit target and stop loss values—just like I do in this video:
The way to move a reward/risk drawing without the menu is to left click, on one of the lines, near the middle of the line between either the entry and the target or between the entry and the stop. Left click again in the same location and then the move will be initiated.

The lines will not be visible, if you are showing the transparent rectangle areas for the reward/risk drawing, but once you click on one of the points, either the target, entry, or stop, you will then see the lines as separated dots. You can then click on the midpoint of one of those lines, to initiate the move.

Regarding, the other suggestions in the prior post we will go over those.

A keyboard shortcut is also now supported. You can add this through Global Settings >> Customize Keyboard Shortcuts >> Trading Keyboard Shortcuts >> Submit Order from Reward/Risk Drawing. The implementation of this does cause some worry because the drawings are iterated through in reverse order and the first encountered reward/risk drawing, is the one the order is submitted for. If for some reason all of the orders are iterated through without a break (not currently the case), and if you do not have order confirmations on, and you are doing live trading and there are more than one reward/risk drawing on the chart, then multiple orders would be sent. We will implement another safety check to prevent this.
Sierra Chart Support - Engineering Level

Your definitive source for support. Other responses are from users. Try to keep your questions brief and to the point. Be aware of support policy:
https://www.sierrachart.com/index.php?l=PostingInformation.php#GeneralInformation

For the most reliable, advanced, and zero cost futures order routing, use the Teton service:
Sierra Chart Teton Futures Order Routing
Date Time Of Last Edit: 2026-11-07 19:17:18
[2026-11-07 19:21:00]
Deenius - Posts: 176
The way to move a reward/risk drawing without the menu is to left click, on one of the lines, near the middle of the line between either the entry and the target or between the entry and the stop. Left click again in the same location and then the move will be initiated.

The lines will not be visible, if you are showing the transparent rectangle areas for the reward/risk drawing, but once you click on one of the points, either the target, entry, or stop, you will then see the lines as separated dots. You can then click on the midpoint of one of those lines, to initiate the move.

I wanted to let you know that I've since found out that it works just as you described, so point 8 isn't necessary after all. But I didn't want to spam the thread. 😄

Thank you so much for the keyboard shortcut! 👍👍👍
[2026-11-16 20:15:14]
User795248 - Posts: 20
Also to add to this great tool a minor tweak needed in that the labels for the optional extension lines do not hide when you turn off the labels under settings.
It Would be helpful if this was corrected so that the tool looks cleaner.
[2026-11-16 21:59:07]
John - SC Support - Posts: 48610
At least in release 2985, setting "Show Labels and Numbers" toggles the text/values for the Target 2/3/4 lines.
For the most reliable, advanced, and zero cost futures order routing, use the Teton service:
Sierra Chart Teton Futures Order Routing
[2026-11-17 08:46:05]
User795248 - Posts: 20
THanks for the reply. I just downloaded the latest version using the "Download current version" in the Menu (which for me seems to be v2982).

See screenshot. Labels are turned off, but the multiplier lines are still showing the prices.
Is there anything I'm doing wrong?

In an ideal world,
1. I'd like to at least have the option to simultaneously show the standard RR labels (which are an essential part of the tool), but hide the multiplier extension's text, so that they're clean, blank lines.
2. These extension labels need to vertically align with the text of the main labels, so that the text doesn't overlay onto the lines itself and in doing so masking the drawings.
3. These extension labels always just show price for me, regardless of which settings I change, whereas the main labels I have set to show tick and currency value, which for me are more useful.

Thank you.
Date Time Of Last Edit: 2026-11-17 09:08:30
imageScreenshot 2026-11-17 083858.png / V - Attached On 2026-11-17 08:40:01 UTC - Size: 38.83 KB - 31 views
[2026-11-17 09:44:40]
Deenius - Posts: 176
Is there anything I'm doing wrong?

Click “Download PreRelease” to get version 2985.
[2026-11-17 17:06:27]
John - SC Support - Posts: 48610
v 2985 is the current release now. So you can update to the current release to get the changes to the Reward/Risk drawing. The instructions to update are here:
Software Download: Fast Update
For the most reliable, advanced, and zero cost futures order routing, use the Teton service:
Sierra Chart Teton Futures Order Routing
[2026-11-17 19:05:19]
User795248 - Posts: 20
Thank you. Yes, v2985 handles this tool much better, sorry about the confusion with this and, well done on your efforts to improve this tool.

May I be so bold as to suggest adding a optional setting with this tool that can auto-preset to a certain RR ratio based upon the 1st 2 clicks (SL and entry)? So the green TP automatically sizes itself at 2:1 for example.
[2026-11-17 21:18:24]
Sierra_Chart Engineering - Posts: 25458
Regarding this:
In an ideal world,
1. I'd like to at least have the option to simultaneously show the standard RR labels (which are an essential part of the tool), but hide the multiplier extension's text, so that they're clean, blank lines.
2. These extension labels need to vertically align with the text of the main labels, so that the text doesn't overlay onto the lines itself and in doing so masking the drawings.
3. These extension labels always just show price for me, regardless of which settings I change, whereas the main labels I have set to show tick and currency value, which for me are more useful.
Is this now all supported the way you are looking for, in the latest release?

Yes we can do this:

May I be so bold as to suggest adding a optional setting with this tool that can auto-preset to a certain RR ratio based upon the 1st 2 clicks (SL and entry)? So the green TP automatically sizes itself at 2:1 for example.

Sierra Chart Support - Engineering Level

Your definitive source for support. Other responses are from users. Try to keep your questions brief and to the point. Be aware of support policy:
https://www.sierrachart.com/index.php?l=PostingInformation.php#GeneralInformation

For the most reliable, advanced, and zero cost futures order routing, use the Teton service:
Sierra Chart Teton Futures Order Routing
[2026-11-19 16:37:11]
User795248 - Posts: 20
Yes, the latest release resolves these issues, thanks for checking.
I look forward to the fixed RR ratio in due course - thanks for adding this to your to-do-list.

To post a message in this thread, you need to log in with your Sierra Chart account:

Login

Login Page - Create Account